Tuesday, November 30, 2010

I condemn the attempt on the freedom of expression of Mr. Federico Alvarez

Mr. Federico Alvarez, a long time resident and now "alleged" Honduran citizen by naturalization, yet a logical and detailed critic of the current and previous administrations, has been told that the process for him to become a Honduran citizen was "flawed" and thus his official citizenship was canceled by the Honduran government. The news were communicated in a press conference by the Ministry of the Interior, Mr. Africo Madrid, who indicated that due to many deficiencies and missing documents in Mr. Alvarez naturalization application, his citizen status had to revert to that of a "legal resident".

The consequence of this act is that Mr. Alvarez cannot intervene in "political activities" within Honduras.In other circumstances, some have interpreted this article of the Honduras Constitution that prohibits foreigners from intervening in political activities as a curtail on the freedom of expression. That is, all foreigners (legal residents or visitors) cannot voice their opinion on political issues at all There is quite a bit of scope of opinion on the interpretation of this article of our constitution, but I simply cannot agree with the interpretation curtailing freedom of expression.

I have certainly protested/condemned and asked in past to disregard foreigners interference in our political affairs and yes the expressions of opinion about our affairs. In the end, the issue here is defining properly what an intervention is, and how does this contrast with the freedom of expression which is almost an absolute right. Certainly we are also free to disregard or condemn ourselves anybody else opinion with equal validity. Mr. Alvarez case is different anyhow.

I publicly raise my voice to protest this clear act of intimidation against the freedom of expression of Mr. Alvarez and a not-so-obscure move to silence all the critics of the current government, including I presume yours truly, and all those who may raise their voice for the proper application of justice, democracy, law and order, respect for the constitution and the Republic, equal protection under the law and the truth. We cannot allow these overt abuses of power to go on.

These acts are clearly designed to silence critics and to proceed with the policies of an autocratic/oppressive government.We condemn all the manipulations and dirty tricks used to revoke Mr. Alvarez nationality. If there was anything wrong with his application, given the long time legal residency status and the integrity of his character, Mr. Alvarez should have been give the opportunity to normalize his situation and then formalize what we believe is compliance with the spirit of the law that grants citizenship to those who want and deserve it for their lifetime.

I cite Mr. Juan Ramon Martinez in La Tribuna and join him in protesting this act, which we hope is that of a lone, misguided and frankly stupid act of a public servant, not an official Honduran government policy.  Read Mr. Martinez column here http://www.latribuna.hn/web2.0/?p=213837


  1. MinInterior Madrid should be fired, forthwith. He's a disgrace to the Government of Honduras and to Honduras as a whole.

  2. I fear that your hope is misplaced, Jose.

    Proceso Digital says that Lobo's announced that another five naturalized citizens could lose their citizenship, including a "Padre Tamayo" (I assume you know who this is; I do not).

    Lobo's actions are a blatant violation of the basic right of free speech and he and his government should be condemned in no uncertain terms throughout Latin America (and the States, for that matter).

    Frankly, I don't understand why Lobo is doing this. He's been working to get Honduras recognized (o mejor dicho, re-recognized) after the events of 2009, so stripping people of their citizenship because they disagree with him will not/not make his job any easier.

    Assuming Lobo's not stupid, why is he doing this? Is he under pressure from extreme right wing people to silence dissent? Not good, not good at all, and definitely not good for Honduras...

  3. Hi Tambopaxi and LG, sorry for delaying publishing your comments. After 1 week of end-of-the-year meetings for the projects I work for in DC, and a 1 week workshop in Nairobi Kenya, I'm finally back home and free to write again. I know its not good for Honduras as this is a throwback to the caudillo days of Mel Zelaya, Roberto Suazo Cordova and Tiburcio Carias (all ex-presidents one time or another of Honduras). Father Tamayo was a priest who was stripped of his citizenship, can't remember under which administration and expelled from the country. He was a critic from the left, community organizer and supposedly organizer of many of the armed left leaning groups in Honduras. He was originally from El Salvador. Again, goes back to the definition of intervention vis-a-vis freedom of speech/expression rights...

  4. Hey, Jose, Welcome back, yeah, I can see you've been busy!

    FYI, I lived in Honduras, 1976-80, and 1987-91, so I got to see Lopez Arellano, Melgar Castro, Policarpo Paz, and then Azcona and Callejas (I also knew Callejas when he was MinAg with Melgar Castro), and yes, I know just what you mean; history repeating itself, which is soooo frustrating. Agh.... Can't we ever/ever do better?

    Sorry, I'm just venting here, but for god's sake, there've got to be some decent, honest people in Honduras capces de hacerlo mejor, cierto? I mean, where the hell are they????

  5. Hola José. Ya estoy siguiendo tu blog, que me parece muy interesante. Tal vez te gustaría chequear el mío: http://lahondurasvaliente.blogspot.com

  6. Nos pareces una persona con grandes ideas, e interesada en Honduras; te invitamos a participar en nuestros foros en The [Discussion] Board TE ESPERAMOS!